Good Company in the Car: The Bigfoot and Murder and Everything Else Podcast

The Long-Unsolved Murder of Kathy Devine

In this gripping episode of "Cold Case Files," the audience is taken back to the eerie Seattle of the 70s, where the chilling tale of 14-year-old Kathy Devine unfolded. After abruptly disappearing following an argument at home, Kathy's mysterious and long-extended silence sends shivers down the spines of her family and friends. The discovery of a body by a local woman sets police in a frantic hunt for answers, bringing Kathy's grim fate under the spotlight.

First-hand stories from Kathy's family, law enforcement representatives, and other pivotal characters build the captivating narrative. Learn the nuanced details of the crime, from the violently discarded physical evidence to the trails leading to the infamous Ted Bundy and finally, William Cosden. This haunting journey into Seattle's grim past is set to keep the listeners riveted.

Get deep into the details of the investigation, blending advanced technology with traditional detective work to unlock this decades-old mystery. A riveting portrayal of how DNA evidence was persevered remarkably for nearly thirty years until scientific breakthroughs enabled a match. The narrative provides an insider view into the intricate labyrinth navigated by the investigators during a time when leaving no digital trace was easily achievable.

The relentless pursuit of justice culminated in the conviction and life sentencing of William Cosden in 2002. The episode concludes with a reflective exploration of forensic science, resilience in detective practices, and the echoing impact of a resolved mystery. Prepare to delve into the intricate knots of this chilling murder mystery, leaving audiences reflecting on the power of determination and technology in solving crimes. (This episode title and description were generated by Artificial Intelligence)

 

A Terrifying 911 Call Alerts Authorities to an Unthinkable Murder

Sabrina Zunich had bounced from one foster home to another until she finally found what seemed to be a safe, secure, and forever home with the Knoefel family. The ultimate manipulation and betrayal by her foster father is unforgivable... 

The Long Arm of the Law Reaches Back 22 Years...

Experience the humor and absurdity of the 'miracle flight', and  then brace yourself for a deeper, unsettling narrative. We unravel a 22-year-old cold case that has only recently come to a close; the unsolved mystery of Timothy Smart's sudden disappearance on August 10, 1995, from Boiling Springs Lakes, North Carolina. Dive deep into the intricate details of the investigation process leading to the chilling confession of Brian Lee O'Daniels who was charged with the murder.

Learn of the hard reality of Timothy’s mother who passed away without learning the truth. We follow the investigation team's ingenious use of satellite images, revealing a desolate burial spot masked by a rusted car. The plot thickens as reluctant witnesses break their silence, and the chilling mystery of Tim’s death finally unravels.

 

A Deep Dive into 'Expedition Bigfoot'

In this humor-filled podcast episode, hosts Jack and Kevin kick-off with a lively debate on neighborhood parking woes, culminating in a much-awaited van finally moving out. Transitioning, they move on to review the popular Discovery Channel series "Expedition Bigfoot." Offering a play-by-play account of the Discovery Channel's "Expedition Bigfoot," the hosts critique the adventurous journey undertaken by a group into the wilds of Alaska. 

Throughout their critique, the hosts evaluate key aspects of the show, from the hosts' identities and motivations, to the show's impact on the belief of Bigfoot's existence. Despite a fruitless search, they recognize the role of such series in fuelling human curiosity in the unknown, concluding that regardless of Bigfoot's existence, people's fascination with the mythical creature is undeniable.

The Kruger Family Tragedy Explained

In this unsettling episode, we delve deep into the harrowing story of the Kruger murders in 2007, in the rural heartland of Minnesota. 

The narrative revolves around main suspect, Michael Zabawa, a man with an uncanny ability to sustain a casual façade in the light of severe allegations. Despite the suspect's evasive and varying narratives, we witness how an initially simple interview escalates into murder charges, with courtroom presentation playing a critical role.

The narrative also brings forward the inspiring resilience of the surviving Kruger family and their strength amidst adversity. Notably, we share the story of Sammy Macht, a young girl spurred by the tragedy to choose a path in forensic science.

 

A Tangled Web of Tragedy & Misdirection

In this sad and unsettling episode, we journey through the labyrinthine twists and turns of a tragic real-life murder mystery that unfolded from a late-night pizza delivery. 

Join us in this distressing recounting, a testament to the darkness that can hide behind routine structures. Prepare to be disgusted by the chilling portrait of a woman seemingly devoid of any conscience in this chilling true crime tale.

Perp Nap: An Unraveling Interrogation

Join our hosts as they navigates through the muddled world of rattlesnakes, and later, into an adrenaline-pumping murder investigation in Pensacola, Florida. The gears shift as we transition into an intense discussion about a murder investigation in Pensacola, Florida. Our episode takes you on an investigative journey into a police interrogation room. The narrative immerses you into the charged confrontation between law enforcement and the prime suspect. 

The episode concludes with a gripping verdict and a live testimony from a mother scarred by the perpetrator's ruthless acts. "Perp Nap: An Unraveling Interrogation" is perfect for crime enthusiasts, psychology buffs, and true crime podcast zealots. 

 

Unveiled Secrets: A Chilling Tale of Love, Betrayal, and Murder

In this gripping episode, we journey into the heart of a chilling tale from Palm Harbor, Florida. Narrated by our hosts, Jack and Kevin, the story revolves around the seemingly natural death of an 85-year-old man, Anthony Tomaselli. The calm veneer of this event shatters when four years later, Anthony Marsh, a local guitarist with a significant connection to Anthony's daughters Linda Roberts and Mary Beth Tomaselli, uncovers an unsettling truth.

Experience the chilling climax where an iPhone recording becomes the cornerstone of a shocking trial, culminating in a verdict that echoes the severity of their crime. 

As the episode concludes, we explore their harrowing prison lives and failed appeal attempts, painting a stark picture of the dire consequences of love, betrayal, and murder. This is an unmissable journey into real-life familial controversy and a stark reminder of the reasons why secrets should remain secret. Don’t miss out. Subscribe and blend into this unforgettable journey of life's darker shades.

 

A young woman is run over by her boyfriend. Or was she?

John Button was accused of running his girlfriend over with his car despite the fact that there was a serial killer in the area who was known to do exactly that. It would be 37 years before the truth was found out...

On a frosty June night in Winnipeg, a woman goes for a walk and never returns home to her family...

Shirley Andronowich had spent an evening at the local bar with her husband. Later, when she arrived home after him, they had an argument and she went for a walk to clear her head. What happened next haunts Winnipeg to this day...

A Young Ohio Woman Goes Missing...

The family of Shannon Graves hadn't heard from her in four months. When the police are finally notified, the search to find her uncovers a bizarre crime...

A mother and daughter were systematically eliminating the rest of their family...

Diane Staudte, and daughter Rachel, had some issues with the father and two oldest siblings. So like any healthy family, they turned to homicide to fix the problem.

A Man, a Plan, a Scam: Bob Duke

Bob Duke was tired of being married and being a father and he decided to kill them both. He almost gets away with it...

A Year in the Rearview Mirror: Our Favorite Episodes from 2023

That year just flew by! Jack and Kevin do a yearend roundup of their favorite episodes from 2023. From Annjette's restaurant to killer grandmas, we picked the best of the best...

Christmas and crime...

It's Christmas break so let's revisit a holiday themed episode from a couple years back. Enjoy the terrifying Adelaide Kay story brought to you by the most exciting true crime channel of all, Hallmark!

A home invasion gone wrong, or a setup? You decide...

The home of the local drug dealer in Chester, New York is invaded by a shotgun wielding intruder, the ensuing beating and murder of the gunmen is not what it seems...

An alleged three-way relationship leads to murder...

Desiree Sunford was a beloved art teacher and loving wife to husband Scot. He returns from a funeral one cold January day to find the home invaded and his wife dead. Then the interrogations and bananas explanations begin...

The Original Flipper TV Show was the Best!

Set in the fictional Coral Key Marine Park, the original tv series of Flipper gave everyone a glimpse into a fantastical world of tropical sea life and adventure! Continuity and accuracy be damned, this was the 1960's! Watching the show from the mossy permafrost of upstate New York was particularly enthralling for a young, perpetually shivering Kevin. 

Jack’s in the hotseat!

It's the holidays so this is just a fun throw away episode where Jack answers fan mail! Rather, ridiculous questions from Kevin. Happy thanksgiving from GCITC to you all!

Between June 2005 and July 2006 a serial killer terrorized Phoenix, Arizona

Bizarrely, it would later be learned there was not one killer but two, and their crimes were not limited to the random killing of pedestrians at night...